What follows is the chapter on Framework Knitters from Geoff Dawes' book "A History of Crich" Landmark Publishing Ltd; transcribed with permission.
Hand-knitted stockings have been made at least since the middle ages and were popular amongst the well-to-do in Tudor times when both woollen and silken hose were available. In about 1589 the Rev. William Lee of Calverton in Nottinghamshire, completed the development of his mechanical knitting frame and framework knitting began as an industry. It was based in London and Nottingham. After about 1640 the trade spread to Derbyshire and followed continually-made improvements to Lee’s frame and the use of worsted yarn spun from wool grown in the neighbourhood of Sherwood Forest. This had the longest and finest staple in England and was probably the equal of any to be found in Europe. From such worsted yarn it was possible to make, on the frame, articles strong enough to compete in wear with hand-knitted hose, which were made from more expensive extra-twisted materials.
In 1700–1715 workmen making plain stockings earned 2s 6d to 3s 6d a day and those on embroidered work up to 5s 0d a day. This was at a time when meat was 1½ d a pound and bread 14 d a stone. On average the hands only worked at the frame for about four days a week and framework knitting was a well-paid ‘luxury trade’. At the beginning of the 18th century the centre of the industry was near its biggest market and in and around London. However, a desire to escape the regulation of the London-based Framework Knitters Company resulted in other places, particularly Nottingham, becoming centres for expansion and development. In 1727 although there were 2500 of Lee’s frames in London there were at least 5,000 in the rest of the Kingdom.
Cotton was first adopted for use on the frame in about 1730 and until about 1770 the cotton thread for hosiery was all imported from India. The expense of the material limited the growth of the industry.
In the late 1750s Jedediah Strutt sponsored an addition to Lee’s frame which meant that ribbed fabrics could be made. The “Derby Rib” hose became very popular. In those days, when elegant men wore knee-breeches, fashion was important to the upper classes and long, fancy hose were in vogue; the demand for different types of hose was high. Also, of course, long- skirted ladies wore stockings and there was great demand for good quality hosiery.
With the development of factory spinning for cotton, the production of better cotton thread and a growth of demand which followed the increase in population beginning about 1780, together with a domestic labour force released from hand-spinning, the conditions were ripe for the rapid expansion of the cotton-hosiery trade.
Framework knitting was established in Crich as early as 1789. It was reported that eighteen hands were then employed in the village in the manufacture of stockings. The availability locally, at Cromford, Lea and Belper, of machine-spun cotton yarn and the greater ease of travel on the newly-built turnpikes meant that it was possible to exploit the labour available in places like Crich which would be cheaper than that at Nottingham.
At the beginning of the 19th century all was not well in Nottingham. In the prosperous times of the late 18th century there had been a great increase in the number of knitting machines available and by 1812 there were 25,000 in the three Midland counties of Leicester, Nottingham and Derby and 29,000 in the country as a whole. The numbers had grown rapidly, not only because of demand and technical development but also partly as a result of the intrusion into the trade by people with spare capital who bought frames for renting to the framework knitters, the vast majority of whom did not own the machines they worked on. In the ‘good’ days the frame rentiers made at least 5% to 10% clear profit on the capital they invested over and above the basic 5% interest they could normally expect on a long-term investment carrying little risk. Established hosiery manufacturers and factors and the middlemen (the ‘Bag Men’) they used as intermediaries in dealing with the domestic framework knitters also rented frames to those whom they supplied with material and who made the products the rentiers sold. With income from frame-rents an important element in the profits of those renting them out, it was in the interests of the rentiers to spread the work around as many frames as possible. Not only was there a considerable number of surplus frames by 1810 but, in the late 1700s, vast numbers oi apprentices had been trained by the masters facing an upsurge in trade. The situation was full of danger for the framework knitters in a period of sluggish trade partly due to changing fashions. Being committed to paying rent for their frames they began to accept lower and lower piece-rates in order to obtain any work at all. By 1835 the income of framework knitters making cotton hose had fallen to between a half and a third of its value in 1780 and during much of this time food prices were much higher than they had been in 1780. The situation was so bad that in January 1812 nearly half the population of Nottingham, some 4250 families, was receiving ‘poor law’ assistance from the rates. In 1811 the frame breaking had started and there followed the so-called “Luddite Riots” (Ned Ludd – or Ludlam – was a simple-minded Leicestershire lad who, when told by his father to “square-up his needles”, that is, place them in a good straight line, took a hammer to them and smashed his frame). The frame breakers were active not only in Nottingham but also in the neighbourhoods of Ilkeston, Holbrook and Pentrich. They, and Crich, are reported as “suffering seriously from the violence of the stocking frame breakers” . The frame breaking carried on until a series of executions in 1816–1817 brought it to a halt.
No Crich men were arrested after the treachery of the hunger-driven “Pentrich Revolution” in 1817, following which three of the ringleaders were executed. These three were:
Jeremiah Brandreth of Nottingham, the leader of the marchers and a framework knitter”; Isaac Ludlam, a Methodist preacher of Wingfield Park and who owned a quarry at Coalburn HilL; and William Turner, a stone mason from South Wingfield.
However, Crich men were probably involved in the uprising for George Weightman, a sawyer of Pentrich (who was tried and found guilty but was spared the death sentence, being transported to Australia for life, along with fourteen other local men ) told a surgeon at Eastwood who attended one of the ‘rebels’ who had been accidentally shot in the leg that “.... men came from Heage, Belper, Crich, South Wingfield, Swanwick, Pentrich, Ripley, Butterley and other places”.
The march of the rioters (about fifty in number) began at Hunt’s Barn at South Wingfield and went off through Wingfield Park looking for arms and recruits. They acquired arms from S. Hardwick of Manor View and went on to Henry Tomlinson’s home at Park Farm. Although Tomlinson had hidden his gun they made him produce it and accompany them on the march; but Weightman let Tomlinson return, as he wanted, to his family after they had gone but a few hundred yards. Some marchers then went on to the home of a widow, Mrs. Hepworth where her servant, Robert Walters, was shot – the only fatality of the insurrection. These men then went on to Pentrich Lane End where they rejoined others who had cut back to Park Lane and knocked-up a Mr. Marriott at the Weir Mill. From there the band set off for Nottingham. The ‘revolution’ ended pathetically near to Kimberley in a tanyard near a stream called the Gilt Brook when the marchers became aware of the approach of a detachment of mounted men of the 15th Regiment of Light Dragoons.
After the arrests following the collapse of the ‘Revolution’ William Lockett, the prosecuting solicitor from Derby, reported to the Home Office the claim that Hugh Wolstenholme, the Curate of Pentrich, had secreted George Weightman in his house at Crich and helped him to get away to Yorkshire, but nothing came of the accusation.
A minor consequence of the Pentrich Revolution was that when a new barn, on the road side of the farmhouse, was built at Barnclose Farm it was designed rather like a fortress; there were no windows on the ground floor but ‘observation and firing slits’ were provided at intervals around the perimeter.
The Luddite revolts prior to the Pentrich Revolution were partly against low wages, partly in opposition to high frame rents, but also to hostility to the new ‘wide’ frames on which cheap and spurious cut-up goods could be made. These, by the end of the Napoleonic Wars, were usually housed in large workshops and were concentrated in the bigger towns.
As suggested above, in Nottingham itself the hosiery trade was in a parlous state and by 1819 men’s wages were down to about five to six shillings a week – for which they were labouring some sixteen to eighteen hours a day. The wages of women and girls were, not surprisingly, less than this. They worked as winders and seamers for sums between 2s 6d and 4s 0d a week. At around this time the better-class workers in Nottingham were being attracted into the lace trade. When good framework knitters in full work could average 11s 6d a week on their frames, the best bobbin-net hands could earn up to 28s 0d and the average lace-worker could get 15s 0d. When the better workers moved into lace they left behind a demoralised workforce with no pride or interest in their work, apathetic about improving their lot, unable to pay to educate their children, or to attend church or “enlarge their minds”. As a framework knitter said rather later:– “a man becomes more like an ass than a man from his excessive labour and want of time to study and learn and intermix with social society”.
Because there was a source of cheap labour in country districts and rather less fear of organised frame breaking, more and more frames, and the problems associated with them, were moved there. The vast majority of these frames were of the older ‘narrow’ frames used for ‘wrought’ or full-fashioned work which, per unit of production (though the quality was higher), was more labour-intensive than the ‘cut-up’ product of the wide frame. It is likely that most of the frames installed in Crich were of the narrow type.
By 1844 there were 245 frames in Crich and Fritchley and in a National Census somewhat later it was recorded that 127 families in the parish were engaged in framework knitting and producing cotton hose. Altogether some 270 people were involved, over 10% of the local population. The women and children would be mostly engaged in winding yarn on bobbins before knitting on the frame could begin and, when the fabric had been knitted, there were the tasks of mending, stitching, seaming and making-up. A woman or a competent child was needed full-time to do the seaming work for two or three stocking knitters.
There is, in Crich, in the Royal Oak Terrace across from the former Parish Room, a fine example of a ‘stockiners shop’ with its long row of windows – good light was essential. Quite a number of such shops in Crich and Fritchley are listed in the 1839 Rating Survey. One was to be found at Thorpe Hill Farm where, Watkins records, Tom Ludlam, an old man who was then running the farm, told him that the girls working in the stockiners shop built there “were serenaded at work by youths discoursing sweet music on a triangle, thus anticipating BBC ideas of ‘Music While You Work’ by a good many years”.
By the 1840s poverty among framework knitters was rife, and probably worse than it had been in Nottingham before the Luddite Riots. In the period 1810–1845 the hosiery workers, especially those in the country, were in a truly miserable condition. By 1842 the price paid for making a dozen pairs of most sorts of stockings was not much more than half that paid in 1814 and country framework knitters were very liable to accept work ‘below the list price’, there being no alternative employment such as was developing in the towns as the factory-based Industrial Revolution got into its full stride. The country framework knitters and their families fed on bread and potatoes, sometimes for weeks together:
“It became a widespread practice to still the cravings of hunger in the adult by opium taken in the solid form and by children as Godfrey’s Cordial”.
Their furniture gradually disappeared, their clothing could scarcely be held together, nothing new had been obtained by many families for so long that they could not remember the time. The dwellings were mostly filthy and abodes of discontent and misery. Children had no scholastic education at all.
In about 1700 a framework knitter could earn an income typical of a skilled artisan, by the 1840s his earnings, if he worked in cotton, had dipped to a level much below that of a labourer. Even so he would be working cruelly-long hours each day and every day at his frame; it was truly a pauper trade.
Poor Law records in Crich show that relief was paid out to local framework knitters and the Census Return contains such entries as “pauper-framework knitter”.
The change in the industry from the prosperity of the 1780s is well illustrated by Felkin’s sketch of his grandfather, William Felkin’s, life. Grandfather William was born in 1745 and bound, as an orphan, as an apprentice framework knitter at the age of ten. At that time the charge to a journeyman knitter for board, lodging and washing was 5s 0d. Meat was 1½ d a pound, butter and cheese 3d a pound and wheat 3s to 4s a bushel. A journeyman’s income could be as much as 30s 0d a week if he were diligent and working at the top end of the fancy-quality scale. In 1783 William bought a new frame for £25 and, over the next thirty-five years he made hose on it before selling it for £10. During that time he only spent £3 on maintaining his frame. When William Felkin began work the usual hours of work were ten on five days a week. One Saturday was allowed for taking-in work and marketing, the alternative was for gardening and domestic matters. In middle life it was necessary for him to work twelve hours and at the time of his death in 1838, aged 93, it was necessary for a framework knitter to work fourteen to sixteen hours a day in order to sustain bare maintenance.
The situation became a public scandal and a Parliamentary Commission of Enquiry was established under Richard Muggeridge. It reported in 1845. The biggest single grievance Muggeridge uncovered was the iniquitous ‘frame-rent’ system. The rent had to be paid (or the knitter could be deprived of his livelihood completely) irrespective of whether the knitter had work in or not. The normal rent in the mid-19th century was 1s 0d a week and, in some villages, a man was paying more for frame-rent than for house rent. Muggeridge reported that by the time the knitters had paid for their materials and had covered the dues of the ‘bag man’, “they have to work, on an average, two full days a week for the charges before they begin to earn one penny for themselves or the support of their families”.
The role of the bag man in framework knitting was crucial. In the 1850s they handled over half of the narrow-frame work and more of that from wide frames. The warehousemen, or ‘hosiers’, were content to accept their services for it enabled them to avoid dealing with large numbers of small-output employees and in practice they got the services of men who were, in effect, managers and foremen at no direct expense to themselves. The country framework knitters endured them for it saved them time in going to the warehouses to collect materials and to deliver their product. Many of the bag men also made an income as receiver or collector of rents, in addition to making a straight deduction from the knitter’s earnings for delivering materials and work. Often they would conceal from the knitter the true piece-rate and pocket the difference. If they arranged for seaming and mending again they would deduct from the earnings of the women who did the work. It was alleged, even in 1783 when the trade was relatively prosperous and there was neither a surplus of frames nor of craftsmen, that bag men were deducting as much as 20% commission on the price being paid by the hosiers for the product of the framework knitters. It was probably even higher when the bag men were in a more powerful position to allocate work to competing knitters desperate to get work.
The knitters were very aware of the bag man’s indulgences in the various deductions he tried to make. There was continuous ill-feeling, but when trade was bad and too many knitters and too many frames were wanting work, the bag man was in a situation which many used unscrupulously.
In the early part of the 19th century many middle men doubled as both bag men and shopkeepers and the knitters were often paid in ‘truck’, i.e. in goods of nominal value bought from a particular shop nominated by the bag man and often owned by him. Again the system was prone to abuse, either by overpricing goods or providing ones of lower than standard quality. Nevertheless the wives of knitters often favoured the system of payment in kind for:– “it effectively keeps workmen from the public-house or beer shop because he is without money and therefore without welcome there and it ensures that his earnings are expended at home on articles almost exclusively consumed by his wife and children”.
The old, old conflict between husband and wife is well illustrated in my book entitled “The Crich Tales” to which ‘Ted the Post’ contributed so handsomely. Ted’s grandfather, who appears in one of the Tales was a bag man serving Crich on behalf of Smedleys Mills at Lea. He also kept a ‘truck shop’ at the end of Prospect Terrace and was a prominent figure in the Primitive Methodist Chapel once on Sun Lane. Even after the passing of various Truck Acts in the middle of the 19th century the custom of payment in truck still persisted, even though by then it was illegal.
By 1850 or so there were about 40,000 knitting frames being operated on domestic premises and the frame-rent system attracted more and more hostility. A Parliamentary Select Committee on Frame Rents was established in 1854 and eventually they were abolished.
Even by 1854 some hosiers, like Biggs of Leicester, had abandoned frame rents, which they compensated for by lowering their piece rates. For their ‘out-workers’ this at least removed a threat associated with lack of work. In the 1850s too there was a move towards factory production in the hosiery trade. Hine and Mundella opened their Nottingham factory in 1851 and even when, later, steam-power was applied to the so-called ‘circular frames’ (by A. J. Mundella and Samuel Morley of Nottingham) it was the wide frames producing the lower quality goods which the new machines superseded. In the best class of goods, in which fashioning in those days meant frequent stopping of the machines, there was no great advantage in the use of steam power, and the country framework knitters using narrow-frames still had a market. Nevertheless, whereas in 1844 there had been 245 frames in Crich, by 1857 the number had reduced to a hundred.
The highest quality work had, of course, always been done on the narrow frame, and it depended greatly on the skill of the knitter. Henry Sulley, a Fritchley man born in 1820, became an expert stockiner and had his work exhibited at the Great Exhibition of 1851. Queen Victoria was so impressed with his product that she ordered a pair of fine cashmere stockings from him. There was a wall plaque commemorating Sulley (who died in December 1886) in the Fritchley Primitive Methodist Chapel at Fritchley until the chapel was converted into a dwelling. The plaque, then in the possession of Joan Wragg, was presented by her to Derby Museum.
Although there was still a place for the hand-operated frame in the production of the highest quality goods even late in the 19th century, the change in production in the period 1850 to 1860 towards the use of power machinery was matched by, and partly stimulated by, a change of fashion. Men were, increasingly, wearing trousers rather than knee breeches. Stockings were becoming ‘under’ rather than ‘outer’ garments and when trousers are worn it is not possible to tell whether it is a full-fashioned stocking or a straight-down, or ‘cut’, lower quality and cheaper stocking that a man has on. Again, as Victoria’s reign developed the fashion preference was for ladies to wear long dresses and long boots out of doors and this again reduced the demand for high quality wrought stockings.
The increased demand for lower quality stockings also came from a new market of working- class customers. Once the price was low enough they started buying stockings in the shops instead of hand-knitting them at home. The new urban wage-earners became a bigger proportion of the growing national population and they were less inclined and less able to have their clothes made at home. They were not content with other people’s ‘cast-offs’ if they could buy new, cheap goods and, of course, they could not afford high quality or ‘bespoke’ garments.
Hence, just as the problems of the hand-operated framework knitter were being tackled by Parliament – far too late to prevent suffering – at last offering regulation about frame rents and, in 1860, establishing a Board for Arbitration and Conciliation of the Hosiery and Glove Trades (which was based in Nottingham and whose first president was A. M. Mundella) the market and the technology in the hosiery industry were changing rapidly. Times for hosiery workers in the newly established factories were a great improvement on those endured by the hand-frame knitters in the early years of the century. In his report for 1866–1867 Mundella was able to report that the past year had been a prosperous one, the demand for hosiery for the last two years having been exceptionally large. By 1880, thanks to the abolition of frame rents, compulsory schooling for children, easier migration, more alternative employment and more stable markets, even the remaining hand knitters had an improved situation, at least as far as regularity of work was concerned.
In the late 1880s adult men on the highest classes of skilled ‘wrought’, or fully-fashioned work, could make 18s 0d and upwards per week. Eventually, however, technological development of hosiery machinery rendered the frame operator redundant, even for the highest quality work. Nevertheless, a few frames were still in use at the beginning of the 20th century in Crich. James Henry’s widow Elsie, born in 1896, who came to Crich in 1908, clearly recalled in 1987 that around 1910, stockiners could still be heard at work in the ‘long room’ at the top of the north-end of Royal Oak Terrace. It was early in the 20th century, in Crich, as in other villages, that the production of framework products slowly vanished.
Until the 1930s there were a few frames collecting dust in stocking shops in the Mount Pleasant area of Crich, but none working. Such textile workers as remained in Crich were then travelling daily to mills at Belper, Cromford and Lea – except for a few outworkers in the village who, as late as the middle 1950s, were employed using small specialist machines installed in their own homes by Smedley’s of Lea Mills. Their task mostly was to link knitted components together and assemble them into garments for wholesaling by Smedleys.
Also on this site is Mrs D.M. Howarth's – A history of Crich Framework Knitters